The Die Hard Eagles Fan, known as “Vedder,” agreed to return the favor and allow us some insight into the mind of an Eagles fan regarding their season, the team, and the matchup this weekend.
How did you become an Philadelphia Eagles fan?
That one is easy. My dad has been a die hard Eagles fan forever. He was an usher at the famous 1960 Eagles-Packers championship game and I have been hearing about it since I was probably 5 years old. Add in the factor that I started following sports at age 6, when the Eagles went to the Superbowl (lost to the Raiders), and it made it easy for me to get interested. When I was a bit older, in the mid-80’s, some of the home games were blacked out. So my dad and I would jump in the car and go scalp 2 tickets and watch. Being at the Vet as a kid was exciting but scary. For some sick reason, the experiences at the games as a kid helped me become a fan.
As a child, I grew up in Redskins country. But, I still followed the Eagles running back, Wilbur Montgomery. Who is your favorite Eagle from your lifetime of experience?
There were plenty of players I loved over the years. Seth Joyner was awesome. “Arkansas” Fred Barnett was a favorite of mine. All time though, it has to be Safety Brian Dawkins. He is everything and anything you would want in a Safety. He’s a leader. He’s a ball hawk. He’s a hitter. A future Hall of Famer in my opinion.
The Eagles have played in two Super Bowls, yet have failed to win. How do you feel about the season thus far?
I feel that they are a good team but not a great team. I feel they have the potential to be in the NFC championship if they could learn from their mistakes and apply those lessons successfully.
I’ve read some commentary that is calling for Andy Reid to resign and/or retire, especially after last week’s loss to the Bears. What do you think?
Those callings are because Eagles fans are emotional and in dire need for a championship. They are passionate and let their emotions get to them. Coach Reid definitely has a lot of flaws, and I will be the first to call him out. If he doesn’t win the big one soon, he will go down as a good coach for planning during the week, but a bad game day coach who was too stubborn and too ignorant to learn from the past.
I’m not certain, but Reid is probably the winningest coach in Eagles history. Are the fans being fair to be so down on him right now?
I would say some fans are definitely down on him but if they consider the alternative, such as some of the junk coaches out there, they should be somewhat grateful for what he brings to the table. Again, if he could work on his flaws, then the sky would be the limit with this team. Unfortunately, time is running out.
I have lived in the midst of the fans of the Philadelphia Eagles for over 10 years now. I attended and graduated from Temple University in Philadelphia. I remember Buddy Ryan and the days of that defense with Reggie White, Jerome Brown, and others. It was a ferocious team. How do you compare today’s Eagles to those of yesteryear?
That core of players from that era (late 80’s-early 90’s) was something special and nothing can compare to them, not the 2004 Eagles Defense nor this current Defense. Defenses like that probably only come around once every 10-20 years. I still have my old VCR tapes of the 1991 season and every summer I watch the “House Of Pain” game as well as the “Body Bag” game. Sorry Warmontco, but with you being a Die Hard Skins fan, I had to bring up the “Body Bag” game!
The city seems to be split on their opinion regarding Donovan McNabb. How do you feel about him as a QB?
I am pro McNabb. His career currently reminds me of the 1st 10 years of the trials and tribulations John Elway went through out in Denver, only to a smaller degree. Obviously Elway was a ton better, but the parallels are the same. McNabb has a rifle arm, is mobile, and uses his ability to step up and around the pocket to make big plays. I don’t blame McNabb not bringing us a championship on McNabb like others do. It is not his fault that the team refuses to give him a consistent running attack. It is not #5’s fault that they refuse to address the WR position with the exception of bringing in TO in 2004. I believe Reid has wasted his opportunity with McNabb and blew it, not taking advantage of his skills and complimenting them with the right offensive philosophy.
Do you believe it is fair to compare him to Randall Cunningham? Why, or why not?
There’s really nothing to compare besides they were both quarterbacks here. I mean, sure, both were athletic and impressive quarterbacks. McNabb is intelligent and can read defenses. Randall just went out there and used his athletic ability to get him by. Randall didn’t have anyone coaching him for most of his career here. McNabb will go down as the Eagles best QB in my book. So no, its not fair as I believe McNabb earned the right not to be compared to another QB who didn’t win much here.
Many speculate that McNabb could be traded after this year to the Chicago Bears. Is this the last year for McNabb in Philadelphia? It very well may be and I certainly hope not. I think Eagles fans who want Kevin Kolb in there are suffering from “don’t know what you got until its gone” syndrome. Kolb might be good sometime in the future, but McNabb brings so much more to the table.
Brian Westbrook, when healthy, can dominate a game. Why isn’t he featured more in the offense? Is it because he has trouble staying healthy? Possibly but I say no. I believe it’s because Andy Reid’s stubbornness to having a balanced attack. Can you imagine the numbers Westbrook could put up if Reid didn’t come out throwing 50 times a game?
With the exception of the acquisition of Terrell Owens, why, in your opinion, do the Eagles seem so reluctant to acquire a top-rated WR’s for McNabb?
I believe its all part of Andy Reid’s philosophy to prove to the world and the rest of the NFL how brilliant he can be. It’s no coincidence that the only year the Eagles brought in a true stud, star WR, they went to the big dance.
Many people, including me, believe that if T.O. was still with the team, the Eagles would have won a Super Bowl by now. Do you agree? Why, or why not?
If TO was still here, this team would be in the toilet. He is a cancer and a time bomb, waiting to explode and break up a team.
I believe the real issue that set off T.O.’s immature emotional stability was McNabb’s refusal to acknowledge T.O. as the MVP of the team. What do you think?
I disagree. I think TO’s a selfish, child who may be bi-polar.
This week the Redskins come to town. What is your prediction, and why?
My prediction is both teams feel each other out in the first half where it will be a defensive struggle. I think one team adjusts better than the other in the 2nd half and it opens up the scoring. I think the Eagles come out in a close game, winning 20-16. I think the Redskins are put in a tough position, having two road games in a row and might be still flying high and living off the past weekend with their victory over the Cowgirls instead of focusing on the present and the Eagles.
You must have noticed that the Redskins are playing with more confidence and effectiveness. What concerns you most about the Redskins offense?
Lots of things. They like to grind it out, wearing down the opposing defense while keeping the ball and thus the other team’s offense off the field. The Eagles for years have been killed by other teams’ Tight Ends and this year is no different. TE Chris Cooley makes me nervous. QB Jason Campbell’s athleticism makes me worry. The Eagles have been troubled in the past by QB’s who are athletic. They need to contain him and make him throw off his back foot. WR Santana Moss will be successful in getting behind the Eagles CBs which makes me nervous. How many times he is successful at it will probably help determine the outcome. RB Clinton Portis is a concern but if the Eagles continue to fill their gaps and be agressive at the line of scrimmage, they can limit him and hopefully put the Redskins in 3rd and long positions. If that happens frequently, with the aggressive nature of the Eagles Defense, it would only be a matter of time until they force QB Jason Campbell into making a mistake.
The Redskins defense is playing extremely well, also. In the past three games, they have been effective in minimizing three powerful offensive teams in the New Orleans Saints, Arizona Cardinals, and Dallas Cowboys. What will the the Eagles game plan against this surging Redskins defense?
It depends on if Westbrook plays and is at 100% or not. If he’s there and back 100%, I would expect the Eagles to set up some screens to Westbrook, especially with some misdirection and fake reverses. The Cowboys still moved the ball downfield many times in the air last week, so I would expect Reid and company to attack in the same fashion.
Who do you think will have the better game: Donovan McNabb or Jason Campbell?
It depends which McNabb comes out in the beginning of the game. He can come out, over pumped and hyped up, throwing balls into the ground and at the feets of receivers or over their heads. This will lead to the sound of the early boo birds which only will feed into McNabb’s performance. If he comes out calm, cool, and collective, then I believe McNabb has better odds of having a better game.
Share This